“Over the last six years, the state of Illinois spent about $320 million on illegal immigrants.”
Illinois state Rep. Bill Mitchell, R-Forsyth, repeatedly slammed a three-year extension of the state’s Expanded All Kids program that was passed in the Illinois House in April. While arguing against the bill, Mitchell claimed that All Kids has spent a fortune on covering illegal immigrants with taxpayer dollars.
“The latest (All Kids) audit said, over the last six years, the state of Illinois spent about $320 million on illegal immigrants,” he said in April.
All Kids is a health insurance program run by the Illinois Department of Healthcare and Family Services that offers comprehensive health care to thousands of children in the state. Expanded All Kids is the portion of the program that covers poor families and undocumented children.
As of the 2013-14 fiscal year, the program had a total enrollment of 52,075 children under the age of 19, of which 30,441 were classified as undocumented.
All Kids has faced criticism over the years for its coverage of undocumented immigrants as well as for allegedly being more expensive and providing less coverage than originally anticipated.
We decided to investigate Mitchell’s claim about health care spending on undocumented immigrants.
Looking at the numbers
Mitchell’s claim is based on several audits of All Kids conducted by William Holland, the Illinois auditor general at the time. The latest available report was released in February 2016 and covers health care costs up until 2014; there is no data available for fiscal year 2015.
Mitchell’s office told PolitiFact that his comment was referring to the amount of money spent between 2009 and 2014.
A press release provided by the office stated that, “none of these costs were matched by the federal government. Illinois taxpayers paid the entire cost for these non-citizens.”
We examined the audit reports to break down the costs of health care associated with undocumented children in Illinois each year.
- FY 2009: $54.9 million
- FY 2010: $59.2 million
- FY 2011: $58.8 million
- FY 2012: $55.7 million
- FY 2013: $48.7 million
- FY 2014: $42.3 million
The total costs of health care during the time period add up to approximately $319.6 million, which matches Mitchell’s claim.
The audit reports also list the costs of services by each category. For example, in the 2013-14 fiscal year, dental services cost $12 million, or around 17 percent of that year’s total costs.
We reached out to the Auditor General’s office and to All Kids for information on how much was spent on undocumented children for each category of health care. We’ll add this information if we obtain it.
The All Kids program confirmed the accuracy of the figures in an email, but did not offer comments on Mitchell’s claim.
How do the yearly costs of health care for undocumented children fit into the overall state budget?
The 2014 Illinois budget was $67 billion. The General Revenue Fund, the part of the budget that contains discretionary spending, was approximately $31 billion. The amount of money spent on undocumented children through the Expanded All Kids program translates to roughly .136 percent of discretionary spending for that year.
Are there hidden benefits to the program?
One question worth exploring is if granting health insurance to undocumented children carries any hidden economic benefits that Rep. Mitchell didn’t account for in his claim.
The health care and immigration experts we interviewed said that health care programs often partly pay for themselves over long periods of time.
First, the children receive direct benefits from being covered, such as decreased mortality and a higher chance of attending college.
Additionally, the state may receive long-term economic benefits. A recent preliminary studyconcluded that, “the government will recoup 56 cents of each dollar spent on childhood Medicaid by the time these children reach age 60.” However, this study was conducted on the federal level, and doesn’t specifically examine undocumented children.
Matt Notowidigdo, associate professor of economics at Northwestern University, told us that hospitals in Illinois often already cover the uninsured without receiving compensation, and may actually benefit from Expanded All Kids.
“If undocumented immigrants already consume a lot of health care in our hospitals but often don’t pay for that care, then one can view this program as helping out hospitals financially,” he said in an email.
It’s hard to use this research to judge Mitchell’s claim because of how specific and small the Expanded All Kids program is. We found no research directly discussing any economic benefits that Illinois would receive from the program.
Mitchell claimed that the state of Illinois spent $320 million on health care for illegal immigrants over the past six years.
The state’s independent audit reports on the All Kids program from 2009 to 2014 support his claim. There’s no direct evidence or research that shows Mitchell failed to mention any important unseen benefits of the program that would significantly change the context of his argument.
We rate this claim True.
Commission on Government Forecasting & Accountability, “State of Illinois budget summary: fiscal year 2014,” accessed July 14, 2016
Chicago Tribune, “Yet another Illinois botched program,” May 25, 2010
Email from Office of State Representative Bill Mitchell, July 12, 2016
Email interview with Matt Notowidigdo, associate professor of economics at Northwestern University, July 13, 2016
National Bureau of Economic Research, “Medicaid as an investment in children: what is the long-term impact on tax receipts?” accessed July 13, 2016
Office of the Auditor General, “Program audit of the covering All Kids health insurance program,” April 2011
Office of the Auditor General, “Program audit of the covering All Kids health insurance program,” October 2012
Office of the Auditor General, “Program audit of the covering All Kids health insurance program,” August 2014
Office of the Auditor General, “Program audit of the covering All Kids health insurance program,” February 2016
Office of State Representative Bill Mitchell, “Mitchell stands with taxpayers in opposition to welfare benefits for illegal immigrants,” April 20, 2016
Phone interview with Julian Reif, Associate Professor of Finance and Economics at the Institute of Governmental and Public Affairs at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, July 13, 2016
WJBC Radio, “Mitchell slams Illinois All Kids extension,” July 7, 2016